The real estate market in Oyster Bay and neighboring East Norwich has seen an active season, with several notable properties recently sold. From versatile investment opportunities to family homes nestled in peaceful, tree-lined neighborhoods, these properties highlight the charm and diversity of Oyster Bay living. Here’s a closer look at a few recent sales.
The first property, a two-family home located on a flag lot at 21 Anstice St. in downtown Oyster Bay, offers both convenience and investment potential. Selling for $775,000 on Sept. 30, 2024, this property includes two units—one with three bedrooms and the other with two—both of which are currently occupied. Positioned within walking distance of the Long Island Rail Road, restaurants, parks, and beaches, the property offers rental income for investors or homeowners seeking to offset mortgage costs. The residence’s roof, only eight years old and its prime location make this property an appealing, turnkey choice in the area’s dynamic rental market.
Nearby, a three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath home at 61 Hill Dr. also recently sold, closing at $850,000 on Aug. 29. Set on a beautifully landscaped one-third-acre lot, this home features an attached garage, hardwood floors, and modern 200-amp service. Nestled on a quiet, tree-lined street, it presents an ideal suburban setting for families while maintaining proximity to Oyster Bay’s amenities. The home’s spacious floor plan and private backyard deck and patio add to its appeal, providing a serene space for outdoor gatherings.
For those seeking the quintessential coastal lifestyle, 73 Peachtree Dr. in East Norwich offers an enticing blend of location and style. This three-bedroom, two-bath ranch was meticulously maintained by its original owners and sold for $820,000 on Aug. 26.
Positioned on the North Shore of Long Island near the Long Island Sound, this ranch-style home boasts a spacious living area with abundant natural light and hardwood floors throughout. Its kitchen, equipped with modern appliances and a cozy breakfast nook, overlooks a beautifully landscaped front yard. The primary suite provides a tranquil retreat with views of the backyard, while the home’s flat property offers ample space for outdoor activities. With convenient access to Oyster Bay’s beaches, parks, and boating facilities, this property captures the essence of Long Island’s scenic, relaxed lifestyle.
Rounding out the recent sales is a classic family home located at 61 Anstice St. in Oyster Bay, which sold for $630,000 on July 19. With three bedrooms, one bath, and a spacious 1,983-square-foot layout, this property is brimming with potential. The first floor offers a family room, eat-in kitchen, formal dining room, and den, while the second floor features three bedrooms and a full bath, leading up to an attic. A large basement with a walkout to a yard adorned with native plantings adds to the home’s charm. Positioned close to the beach and town amenities, this home offers an appealing entry point to Oyster Bay for families or those seeking to renovate.
These recent sales reflect Oyster Bay’s enduring appeal, blending history and natural beauty with a vibrant community atmosphere. From investment-ready properties to family-friendly homes, the area’s real estate offerings cater to diverse tastes, making Oyster Bay and its surroundings a prized destination on Long Island’s North Shore.
